[%] polar      ARQM       DLR      GISS    GOCART       KYU       LOA      LSCE     MATCH     MOZGN   MPI_HAM      PNNL     TM5_B   UIO_CTM   UIO_GCM      ULAQ       UMI   average

        DUST     19.03               33.66     46.45     56.98     37.23     28.66     26.11     30.54      2.73     45.67      8.14      2.34     21.49     68.50     34.38     30.79
         SO4     28.90                5.04      8.51      0.82     27.11     29.13     41.01     25.92     52.16     21.81     31.20     40.09     21.76     14.42     36.17     25.60
          BC      2.14                0.47      0.85      7.65      0.88      1.87      2.01      1.96      0.35      0.67      2.34      0.39      3.77      3.52      2.64      2.10
         POM     24.33                2.30      3.51      5.18      7.86     12.17     17.80     11.96      3.45     11.90      6.73      3.20      6.80      5.73     16.10      9.27